Surfbird Money

Acquisition Shareholders have voted

Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc. acquisition by American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.: what happens to stock options and RSUs

American Family Mutual is buying Bowhead Specialty for $34.00 per share in cash; shareholders voted on November 13, 2026. Vested RSUs are paid $34.00 per share. Unvested RSUs (other than the CEO's) are converted into an interest in a cash escrow funded at $34.00 per share, which typically pays out as the awards would have vested; check the proxy for the release terms.

Buyer
American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I.
What holders receive
$34.00 per share in cash
Agreement signed
August 2, 2026
Shareholder vote
November 13, 2026
Expected closing
Not stated in the filing

How equity awards are treated

Vested RSUsCashed out at $34.00
Unvested RSUsConverted into an interest in an escrow account funded with $34.00 per share (CEO awards treated separately)
Performance awards (PSUs)mentioned; terms vary

Estimate your payout at $34.00 per share

Options pay the spread between the deal price and the exercise price; options priced at or above $34.00 usually pay nothing. Whether unvested awards pay now or later depends on the treatment above. Before taxes.

What this means for your taxes

  • Shares you own outright are sold for cash at closing. That is a taxable sale: the gain over your cost basis is a capital gain, long-term if you have held the shares more than a year at closing. For shares from vested RSUs, your basis is generally the value already taxed at vesting (it was on your W-2).
  • Options and RSUs paid in cash run through payroll as wages: income tax plus Social Security and Medicare. Employers usually withhold federal income tax at a flat 22%, or 37% on supplemental wages above $1 million in the calendar year (IRS Publication 15). If your top bracket is higher than 22%, withholding can fall short and you may owe more when you file; an estimated payment avoids a surprise.
  • Incentive stock options that are cancelled for cash generally do not get ISO treatment: the payment is taxed like wages, the same as non-qualified options.
  • ESPP shares sold in the deal within 2 years of the offering date or 1 year of purchase are a disqualifying disposition: part of the gain is taxed as ordinary income.

General rules, not advice for your situation. Your award agreement and the merger agreement control. Full guide: stock options and RSUs in an acquisition →

Source

From the company's SEC filing: DEFM14A (accession 0001140361-26-039513). Last checked against the filing on November 19, 2026. Found an error? Corrections are made the same day; see how we check.

Questions

What will Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc. shareholders receive?

Under the merger agreement, holders receive $34.00 per share in cash.

What happens to Bowhead Specialty Holdings Inc. stock options and RSUs?

Vested RSUs: Cashed out at $34.00; Unvested RSUs: Converted into an interest in an escrow account funded with $34.00 per share (CEO awards treated separately); Performance awards (PSUs): mentioned; terms vary

When will the deal close?

The filing does not give a specific closing date; closing depends on approvals.